Core practice
Medical malpractice
Failure to diagnose, surgical error, medication error, hospital negligence and birth injury, tried in Nassau, Suffolk, the Bronx and across New York.
A medical malpractice case is built on the medicine, so that is where we start. A registered nurse on staff reads your chart first, and we retain the expert before we file, not after.
We start with the medicine
The order matters, because the chart either supports a departure or it does not, and everything after that is expensive.
- Intake, same day. We ask the questions that establish the case type, the county and the deadline.
- Nurse review. A registered nurse reads the record and flags the interval where the standard of care was arguably breached.
- Attorney review. An attorney reviews causation: whether the departure from the standard of care caused the injury.
- Expert retention. A physician in the relevant specialty reviews before anything is filed, as the certificate of merit requires.
- Suit, and the decision to try it. We take cases to trial when the offer does not match the injury. The $80 million Bronx result was a verdict, not a settlement.
We review the records and have an expert weigh in before anything is filed, because that review decides whether there is a case.
It is also why we advance every case expense, including the clinical review. If we are wrong about your chart, that is our cost, not yours.
What has to be proven, in order
1. A provider-patient relationship
The clinician owed you a duty of care. This is rarely contested, but it decides who can be named. In a hospital case, whether a doctor was an employee or an independent attending often determines whether the hospital is on the hook at all.
2. A departure from the standard of care
Not a bad outcome. A departure. The standard is what a reasonably prudent practitioner in that specialty would have done in those circumstances, and it is established by an expert in the same field, not by hindsight.
3. Causation
The hardest element, and the one most cases fail on. The departure has to have caused the injury. A missed diagnosis only matters if catching it would have changed the outcome, and proving that requires a physician willing to say so under oath.
4. Damages
A measurable harm. In catastrophic cases that means a life care plan: future medical costs, lost earning capacity and the cost of care over a projected lifetime, built by economists and rehabilitation experts.
New York also requires a certificate of merit
Before a malpractice complaint is filed, the attorney must certify that a physician has reviewed the facts and believes there is a reasonable basis for the action. This is why a firm that cannot get an expert to look at your chart cannot file your case, and why a free review is worth having even if you are told no. We do this review up front, at no cost to you.
Every result has its own page, with the venue and the medicine
A case is only useful to you if you can see whether it resembles yours, so each one is published with the venue, the medicine and what the defence argued rather than as a number in a list. All verdicts and settlements.
By injury
Cases we handle
- Misdiagnosis
- Failure to Diagnose
- Delayed Diagnosis
- Surgical Error
- Anesthesia Errors
- Emergency Room Error
- Medication Error
- Prescription Error
- Pharmacy Malpractice
- Nurse Error
- Cancer Malpractice
- Stroke Medical Malpractice
- Heart Attack Malpractice
- Hip Replacement
- Gastric Bypass Injury
- Medical Malpractice and Legal Definitions
Recognition
Verdicts and settlements
Results in this area
$80,000,000
verdict
Birth injury verdict, Jacobi Medical Center
Duffy & Duffy obtained an $80 million verdict against Jacobi Medical Center in Bronx County for a young man disabled by a birth injury.
Trial counsel: James LiCalzi Read the case ›$109,000,000
verdict
Verdict for a Brain-Injured Plaintiff and his Wife
$109,000,000.00 Duffy & Duffy secured a $109 million verdict on behalf of a brain-injured plaintiff and his wife – the highest malpractice verdict in…
Read the case ›$60,000,000
verdict
Verdict for a 26 Year Old Girl Who Suffered from a Surgical Error
$60,000,000.00 verdict for a 26 year old girl who suffered a lacerated vagus nerve during Nissen Fundoplication surgery.
Read the case ›Before you call
Frequently asked questions
What is medical malpractice, in plain terms?
Medical malpractice is an injury caused by a healthcare provider departing from the accepted standard of care for their specialty. Three things distinguish it from a bad outcome. There has to be a departure from what a reasonably prudent practitioner would have done, that departure has to have caused the injury, and the injury has to be measurable. A treatment that fails despite everything being done correctly is not malpractice, however devastating the result.
How do I know whether I have a case, before I hire anyone?
You mostly cannot, and neither can a firm, until somebody reads the chart. What you can do is establish whether the timing works and whether the case type is one the firm actually tries. From there a nurse reads the record, and if it does not support a departure we say so. There is no cost for that review and no obligation attached to it.
What does it cost?
Nothing up front. Medical malpractice work in New York is done on contingency, meaning the fee is a percentage of a recovery and there is no fee if there is no recovery. Case expenses, which in a malpractice case include expert physician review and can be substantial, are advanced by the firm. In New York the contingency fee in a medical malpractice case is set on a sliding scale by statute rather than negotiated freely.
Will I have to go to trial?
Most cases resolve before a verdict. The reason to ask a firm about trial anyway is that the willingness to try a case is what determines the offer. The $80 million result on this site was a verdict, which means the case was tried rather than settled, and defendants price offers partly on whether they believe a firm will go that far.
The hospital was a city hospital. Does that change anything?
Yes, and it is the change that catches people. A claim against a municipal or public hospital, which includes the NYC Health + Hospitals facilities, requires a notice of claim within ninety days. That is under a tenth of the usual window. If the care you are asking about happened at a city or county facility, the date matters more than anything else on this page.
We answer common questions about
Contact us
Our offices
Bronx, NY
388 Canal Place, Studio #404Bronx, NY 10451
(516) 394-4200
Directions
By Appointment Only
Free consultation
Talk to a lawyer about what happened
Tell us what happened. We will tell you whether you have a case, and if you do not, we will tell you that too.
or
Request a free case reviewFree consultation. No fee unless we recover for you. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.






