< Back to all articles

New York Woman’s Medical Malpractice Case Could Be Dismissed at Trial after Prior Denial of Summary Judgment – Holmes v. Bronx-Lebanon Hospital Center

Written June 1, 2015

As with other types of personal injury cases, the plaintiff in a medical negligence case has a burden to prove that the defendant against whom recovery is sought owed a duty of care to the plaintiff, that the defendant breached that duty, and that the plaintiff sustained damages (such as additional medical expenses, lost time from work, or pain and suffering) as a result of the defendant’s breach of duty. This must be shown by a preponderance of the evidence.

In most medical malpractice cases, the plaintiff must retain an expert witness to render an opinion as to the particular duty of care owed to the plaintiff and to determine whether the duty was breached. If the plaintiff fails to do this, his or her case will be likely be dismissed. In a recent case, a trial court had initially ruled that the plaintiff had made out a prima facie case of medical negligence but later dismissed the case on summary judgment.

The Facts of the Case

In Holmes v. Bronx-Lebanon Hospital Center, the plaintiff was a woman who believed that the defendant hospital had committed an act of medical negligence by not performing appropriate diagnostic testing when she visited the emergency room in 2008. She filed suit in the Supreme Court for Bronx County, seeking damages for medical malpractice.

Proceeding in the Trial Court

The hospital moved for motion for summary judgment, and the trial court denied the motion on the basis that the plaintiff had made out a prima facie case under the medical malpractice laws. The case proceeded to trial. After the plaintiff’s expert testified, the trial court dismissed the plaintiff’s complaint. She appealed.

Decision of the Appellate Court

On appeal to the Appellate Division of New York, First Department, the court affirmed, ruling that the trial court’s initial finding on the defendant’s motion for summary judgment did not preclude dismissal of the complaint after the presentation of her case at trial.

The court found that the plaintiff had not established liability through her expert witness’s “conclusory assertion” concerning the hospital’s failure to do certain testing. According to the court, the witness’ testimony did not establish that such testing would have revealed inflammation or swelling. In so holding, the court noted that the operative report of the surgeon who later performed an extensive appendectomy on the plaintiff showed that the swelling would not have been apparent until the woman had been discharged from the hospital. The court also noted that the expert did not explain how the hospital’s failure to perform an appendectomy allegedly contributed to a perforation with which the plaintiff was later diagnosed.

To Get Started on Your Long Island Medical Malpractice Case

If you believe that you or a family member may have been the victim of an act of medical malpractice, it is imperative that you speak with an attorney about your case as soon as possible. Strict deadlines apply in personal injury cases, and a delay could mean no recovery. Call Duffy & Duffy today at (516) 394-4200 and ask for an appointment to come in and speak with one of our experienced medical malpractice attorneys. We represent injured people in New York, the Bronx, and Queens, as well as elsewhere in the New York area.

Related Blog Posts

Patient’s Medical Malpractice Claim for Lack of Consent Survives Summary Judgment by New York Hospital and Doctor – Bradshaw v. Lenox Hill Hospital

Expert Witness Testifies in Medical Malpractice Case

Choose Duffy & Duffy

The injury attorneys at Duffy & Duffy have dedicated their practice to helping victims who have been hurt as a result of someone else’s carelessness. Our trial lawyers have years of experience litigating and resolving negligence claims, and we can use our knowledge and skill to pursue the compensation you deserve.

  • $800,000,000+ in verdicts and settlements
  • 250+ malpractice cases settled
  • 80+ multi-million dollar settlements

Schedule a Consultation

Please complete the form below and a member of our team will get in touch with you as soon as possible.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.